2021 Prize Winners
- Olivia Votava: Murder, Mystery, and Serial Magazines: The Evolution of Detective Stories to Tales of International Crime.
- Joseph Hiller: Como un detective salvaje: Gathering Small Press, Experimental, and Untranslated Latin American Literature.
2017 Prize Winners
- Jason Todd: Century of Upheaval: War and Revolution in China and Around the World
- Colin O'Leary: The "Library of Forking Paths": Jorge Luis Borges, His Literary Antecedents & His Descendents
- Jessica Lee: Hamilton to Homer: A Mythoholic's Journey to Becoming a Classicist
2015 Prize Winners
- Anne Steptoe: Look Homeward: Journeying Home through 20th Century Southern Literature
(Winner, Essay Prize--2015 National Collegiate Book Collecting Contest) - Andrew Patty: Masculinity, Race, and a Southern University: An Exploration of the Role of Fraternities in College Life
- Claudia Dantoin: A British Homecoming: Growing Up Alongside Austen, Dickens, and Daul
2013 Prize Winners
- Ashley Young: New Orleans' Nourishing Networks: Foodways and Municipal Markets in the Nineteenth Century Global South
(Winner, 2nd Prize--2013 National Collegiate Book Collecting Contest) - Kenny Gould: Oxford University: Two Centuries of Magical History
2011 Prize Winners
- Mitch Fraas: Anglo-American Legal Printing 1702 to the Present
(Winner, 1st Prize--2011 National Collegiate Book Collecting Contest) - Orion Teal: The Life of the Party: Experiencing American Communism
- Jacob Golan: Oral Fixation
2009 Prize Winners
- Cynthia Greenlee-Donnell: African Voices
- Tyler Huffman: Islam and the Middle East
2007 Prize Winners
- Jennifer Welsh: Perspectives on Medieval and Early Modern Europe
- Elizabeth Boudreau: Tracing My Emergence
